Enjoy a Meal in Newburgh, IN

Chow down at a combination pizzeria and sandwich shop

Looking to try something new for dinner? Order up some classic thin-crust pizza at Fat Boy's Pizza Newburgh. Our pizzeria churns out pie after delicious pie, topped with sizzling, savory sauce and fresh ingredients.

All of our pizzas are thin-crust and made-to-order using only the freshest ingredients. Our pizza is carry-out only, but we do offer delivery through Door Dash. You can get pizza for your event or have it delivered to your home for dinner. Call 812-518-3061 now to order pizza, sandwiches, sides and more from a pizzeria in Newburgh, IN.

Enjoy the taste of authentic thin-crust pizza.


Order our signature Stromboli for lunch.


Choose a tasty side to go with your meal.


Serve pizza at your next corporate event.


Why should you come to Fat Boy's Pizza Newburgh?

We started this little shop in 2016. With some hard work and lots of sweat, we turned this former dance studio into a fast-paced carry-out pizza shop. We were on the way to getting this tiny building ready to start rolling some pies out the door.

We certainly couldn't do it without all our customers and we really appreciate all the love you guys have shown us. Someday soon, we're looking to expand to a full dine-in restaurant. We hope to see you all getting some pizza really soon.

Pick up something yummy from our sandwich shop

Pick up something yummy from our sandwich shop

As yummy as it is, pizza can't make up your entire diet. Break it up with delicious dishes like Stromboli and chicken wings from our sandwich shop. Enjoy chicken wings in a variety of flavors:

  • Naked
  • Buffalo
  • BBQ
  • Garlic parmesan
Want to give your office a special treat? Use our catering services. We can bring pizza or sandwiches to any work lunch or corporate event. Contact us today to learn more about our sandwich shop in Newburgh, IN.

  • Fat Boy's Pizza Newburgh

    10722 Highway 662 West
    Newburgh, IN 47630


    Call Us
    Phone: (812) 518-3061

    Mon: Closed
    Tue: 4:00PM-9:00PM
    Wed: 4:00PM-9:00PM
    Thu: 4:00PM-9:00PM
    Fri: 4:00PM-9:00PM
    Sat: 4:00PM-9:00PM
    Sun: 3:00PM-8:00PM

    Lunch hours:
    Tues-Fri: 10:00am-1:00pm

Contact Us Now