The specialty pies we make at Fat Boy's Pizza Newburgh are sure to satisfy any crowd. Pick up a pizza for your family, your friends or just yourself. You can get personal pizzas as well as medium and large ones.

Instead of our house-made pizza sauce, we can use:

  • Ranch
  • Buffalo
  • Homemade barbecue sauce

Call 812-518-3061 now to order a pizza in Newburgh, IN.

Dig into a classic thin crust pizza for dinner tonight

You can pick up a thin crust pizza from our carry-out pizzeria. All of our pizza pies come with that traditional thin crust that you've loved all your life. It all starts with homemade, hand-tossed dough. We add our in-house pizza sauce and fresh, tasty ingredients. Then, we cook your pizza in a brick oven for that unique, old-fashioned taste that can't be replicated by electric ovens.

Our two top-selling pizzas are meat lovers and supreme. You can also order pizzas like:

  • Chicken bacon ranch
  • Barbecue chicken
  • Buffalo chicken
  • Stromboli pizza
  • Ring of fire

Contact us today to find out more about our thin crust pizza in Newburgh, IN.